First Run Reviews

 Best off broadway show I've seen!, March 13, 2005

Theatre Online

I've been to a lot of plays, but this is by far one of the best i've ever seen. The cast is phenomenal, there's this incredible energy that permeates from the cast,and for two hours you get swept away by it. Allie Mulholland and Aubrey Plaza are so convincing as Jim and Judy that they would certainly make James Dean and Natalie Wood proud. Joshua Blaylock is the so riveting as Plato that if Sal Mineo were still alive, Joshua would certainly give him a run for his money. Courtney Merritt who plays Judy's younger sister Belle manages to turn a very small role into a very memorable one. Her facial expressions are priceless and with her braids and dimples she's absolutely adorable. The rest off the cast is also incredible, I wish there was enough space to rave about every last one of them. Overall a wonderful experience. I definitely plan to go back and see it again. It's a must see for any theater lover!